Skip to the guide
All guides
Painting

Gouache vs Watercolor: Opacity, Layering, Paper and Cost Compared

Gouache covers, watercolor glows. A side-by-side table, a four-question decision guide, opacity counted color by color from the maker's own charts, a price-per-ml check and one test strip to try both paints.

By Lionel Rutledge ·

On this page
Gouache vs watercolor – Open jars of thick, opaque gouache in a cardboard box

Choose gouache if you want to paint light colors over dark ones and cover your mistakes. Choose watercolor if you want thin, see-through layers where the white paper makes the light. Both paints usually share the same binder, gum arabic, and both soften again with water after they dry. The real difference is how the paint is built, and that changes how you plan every painting.

Blick's guide puts the build in one line. Gouache uses "larger pigment particles packed more tightly together, often with added opacifiers like chalk or titanium white." Watercolor uses finely ground pigment in a thin film, so light passes through it and bounces off the paper.

Gouache and watercolor side by side

The short version: gouache covers, watercolor glows, and almost everything else follows from that. The table rests on Blick's guide, Winsor & Newton's color tables and our own price sum.

Gouache and watercolor side by side
WatercolorGouache
BinderGum arabic, traditionally (Blick)Gum arabic, often with opacifiers (Blick)
PigmentTypically finer particles, less pigment for the binderTypically larger particles, more pigment for the binder
Covers what is below?Mostly no; varies by color (see the counts below)Mostly yes; varies by color
Where the light comes fromThe white paper you leave unpaintedWhite paint you add on top
Re-wets when dry?YesYes (acrylic gouache: no)
Shift on dryingDries lighterLights dry darker, darks dry lighter
FinishLuminous, satin to matteVelvety, matte
Edges and textureBlooms on wet paper, some colors granulate; edges soften or harden as the water driesFlat, even color and clean shapes; no Designers Gouache color is marked granulating
Usual surfacesWatercolor paperWatercolor paper, plus Bristol, illustration board and toned paper
Permanence (W&N ranges)4 of 115 professional colors below "Permanent"; none in Cotman13 of 89 colors "Moderately Durable" or "Fugitive"
Price per ml, same pigment, one maker$0.62 to $2.74 (two ranges, five tube sizes)$1.00 (one 14 ml tube)
Good forLandscapes, botanicals, portraits, urban sketchingDesign work, posters, illustration, flat color

Rows without their own link come from the same Blick guide. The opacity, granulation and permanence counts come from Winsor & Newton's color tables, and the price row is our own sum from its store. All are explained further down.

Gouache vs watercolor – A used metal tin of watercolor half pans

Which one should you start with?

Answer the questions in order and stop at the first clear answer. The tree is my simplification of the sources on this page, not a rule. Whichever paint wins, the rest of our painting guides for beginners build on it.

  1. Do you want to put light colors on top of dark ones, or paint over a slip? Yes: start with gouache. No: go to question 2.
  2. Do you love soft edges, color that runs into wet paper and the paper glowing through? Yes: start with watercolor, and plan your white areas before you paint. No: go to question 3.
  3. Is your first project flat shapes: a poster, a card, simple illustration, lettering? Yes: start with gouache. Not sure: go to question 4.
  4. Still torn? Buy one tube of each in the same color and paint the test strip at the end of this page. It costs two tubes, not two sets.

So is gouache easier than watercolor? Blick calls gouache "often considered more forgiving", because you can paint light over dark and change your mind. That is forgiving about plans, though, not about technique. Gouache still lifts, shifts and cracks, as the next sections show.

"Opaque" and "transparent" go color by color

Watercolor is not always see-through, and gouache does not always cover. Makers rate every color on its own. On 13 Nov 2026 I counted the opacity codes in Winsor & Newton's own color tables:

"Opaque" and "transparent" go color by color
Winsor & Newton rangeColorsTransparentSemi-transparentSemi-opaqueOpaque
Professional Watercolour11542211735
Cotman Watercolour48300612
Designers Gouache89112265

So about three in ten of that maker's professional watercolors are rated opaque. Almost half of those (16 of 35) are cadmium or cadmium-free yellows, oranges and reds. The rest include earth reds, blacks, dark mixes such as Indigo and Neutral Tint, and Titanium White. And one in four of its gouaches is only semi-opaque, including Lemon Yellow, Primary Yellow and Primary Red.

The same pigment can land on opposite sides. Both tables list the pigment code for each color, so you can match them:

"Opaque" and "transparent" go color by color
Pigment codeWatercolor (Professional)Gouache (Designers)
PB29French Ultramarine: transparentUltramarine: opaque
PV19Permanent Rose: transparentPermanent Rose: opaque
PB27Prussian Blue: transparentPrussian Blue: opaque
PR83Alizarin Crimson: transparentAlizarin Crimson: semi-opaque
PR108Cadmium Red: opaqueCadmium Red: opaque

Same pigment, different paint: the recipe makes the difference. Winsor & Newton says the difference between its watercolor and gouache whites "is the amount of pigment in the paint". Cadmium red is rated opaque in both ranges.

What this means for you: in watercolor, an opaque color such as cadmium red hides part of the layer below. That matters when you glaze one color over another. In gouache, a pale yellow may not hide a dark shape. Check the maker's color chart before you trust the word "gouache" or "watercolor" on the tube.

The same charts show a second difference: how well each color lasts. Winsor & Newton rates permanence, its word for durability on paper, from "Extremely Permanent" down to "Fugitive" (terms explained). In Designers Gouache, 13 of 89 colors are "Moderately Durable" or "Fugitive", mostly pinks, reds and violets such as Opera Rose and Magenta. In Professional Watercolour it is 4 of 115, and in Cotman none.

That fits Blick's note that designer gouache aims for "reproduction-ready brilliance, sometimes at the expense of lightfastness". If a painting will hang in daylight, check the rating of each color first. The watercolor chart also marks granulation, the grainy texture some pigments leave as they settle into the paper: 36 of 115 professional colors carry the mark. No Designers Gouache color does.

Can you use gouache as watercolor?

Partly. Thinned with plenty of water, gouache behaves more like watercolor, Blick says. You can lay washes and soft layers with it. But gouache gets its cover from "larger pigment particles" and often added opacifiers. Blick says that denser structure "scatters light at the surface instead of letting it pass through". My reading of that, not a test: thinned gouache tends to get paler rather than glow. The paper does not shine through it the way it does through a transparent watercolor.

My take: one gouache set is a fair start if you mostly want flat color and the odd wash. It is no replacement if luminous washes are what you are after. Going the other way is easier. To make watercolor more opaque, add white: Blick calls a little white gouache "a quick way to increase opacity".

You do not need new tools to try both. Blick says watercolor brushes "work well with gouache"; just rinse well, because gouache "can build up near the ferrule" if it dries in the brush. Watercolor comes in pans and tubes. In the colors I checked, Winsor & Newton's US store sells its Designers Gouache only in tubes: 14 ml, plus 37 ml for the whites. Both paints re-wet on the palette, so squeeze out small amounts and reuse what dries.

Layering and fixing mistakes

In watercolor you plan the light first. In gouache you can add it last. Blick says watercolor artists "traditionally work from light to dark, preserving the white of the paper for highlights". Gouache lets you go either way: "Paint light over dark or dark over light, rework as you go."

The catch is the same for both paints. Dry layers soften when they get wet again. Blick warns that with traditional gouache, "new layers may disturb the colors beneath them, and darker passages can show through lighter ones." Use one confident stroke on a dry layer. Scrubbing turns the color below into mud.

Thick gouache can also crack. Winsor & Newton gives two causes. "If insufficient water is used to dilute the colour, the thicker film may crack as the paint dries on the paper." And later layers "may show cracking if the under layer absorbs binder from the wet colour."

So what are the disadvantages of gouache? Re-wetting, a color shift on drying and cracking when used thick. Watercolor's weak spot is the opposite: highlights must be planned from the start, and Blick notes that some pigments "stain the paper and resist lifting".

Will the color change when it dries?

Yes, both paints shift, in different directions. Blick's table says watercolor "dries lighter". For gouache, "lights dry darker, darks dry lighter". Some guides say gouache simply dries darker. That is only half the rule, and the wrong half for your dark colors.

Does gouache dry faster? Some guides say so, but I found no paint maker that gives drying times for either paint, so treat any speed claim as a tendency, not a rule.

The fix is the same for both. Paint a small swatch of each mix on a scrap of the same paper and let it dry before you commit. A swatch takes seconds and saves you repainting a large area.

Paper for each paint

Watercolor paper works for both, so one pad covers your first tries. Blick lists watercolor paper as the surface for watercolor. For gouache it adds Bristol, illustration board and toned paper, since gouache covers the surface instead of letting it show through.

Watercolor leans on the paper more. Blick says "the paper plays an active role", and rough and cold-press surfaces "help control how water moves". Gouache needs a sheet that stays flat. Blick says it can crack "especially on flexible paper or in heavy layers". It suggests heavyweight watercolor paper, illustration board or a rigid panel. If you buy one pad for both paints, buy heavy watercolor paper.

What does each cost per ml?

Gouache is not automatically the cheaper paint. It depends on the range you compare it with. On 13 Nov 2026, Winsor & Newton's US store listed the same pigment, PB29 ultramarine, at these prices:

What does each cost per ml?
TubeSizePrice (USD)Per ml
Designers Gouache Ultramarine14 ml$13.99$1.00
Professional Watercolour French Ultramarine5 ml$13.69$2.74
Same14 ml$24.79$1.77
Same37 ml$41.79$1.13
Cotman Watercolour Ultramarine8 ml$6.89$0.86
Same21 ml$12.99$0.62

Per ml, that gouache costs less than the maker's professional watercolor and more than its Cotman range. The color matters too. Winsor & Newton sorts colors into price series. Ultramarine gouache is series 1 and French Ultramarine watercolor series 2, while Cadmium Red is series 4 in both, so a cadmium tube costs more in either paint.

Per ml is only half the sum. You thin watercolor a lot, and Blick says its depth is "often achieved using a relatively small amount of paint". Gouache is used thicker, so a tube may empty faster. I found no source that measures how far each tube goes, so treat the per-ml price as the floor of the real cost, not the whole story.

The cheapest start for either paint is the same. Buy one color, not a set. A 24-color box will still be in the shop when you know what you like.

Can you use them together?

Yes. Blick notes that "plenty of artists use both, sometimes in the same painting." Winsor & Newton says its gouache is "fully intermixable with watercolour". It adds that its gouache whites are "frequently used to create highlights on watercolour paintings".

Blick's tips for mixing the two:

  • Build the painting in watercolor washes, then add gouache for highlights and details.
  • Let the watercolor dry fully before the gouache goes on, or you get mud.
  • Gouache mixed into watercolor makes it more opaque and more matte.

That is one maker's range and one retailer's advice. Test any other brand pair on a scrap first.

Acrylic gouache is a third paint

Acrylic gouache looks like gouache but behaves differently once dry. Blick explains that it uses "an acrylic polymer binder instead of gum arabic" and is water-resistant when dry, so you can layer hard without lifting the paint below.

That solves the re-wetting problem, but you lose the softening that lets you fix an edge later. It is also harder on brushes, so rinse them often. Everything above about re-wetting applies to traditional gouache only.

Try both on one strip

This is a proposed exercise, not a record of one we painted. Your result depends on your tubes and paper. You need a strip of watercolor paper about 5 × 20 cm (2 × 8 in). Add one dark and one light color in each paint, a brush, two jars of water and a paper towel.

  1. Split the strip. Draw a pencil line down the middle. Write "W" on the left half and "G" on the right.
  2. Paint the dark band. Paint the dark color across both halves: watercolor on the left, gouache on the right. Let it dry fully.
  3. Paint the light color over it. Use the same order, one stroke each, no scrubbing.
  4. Stop and check. On the gouache half the light color should hide most of the dark band. On the watercolor half the dark should still show through. If your gouache does not cover, look it up in the maker's color chart: it may be a semi-opaque color.
  5. Test the re-wetting. Once dry, touch a clean wet brush to each half for three seconds, then dab it with the towel. Note how much color comes up.
  6. Compare wet and dry. Look at your light color now. Did it dry lighter or darker than when you painted it?

Keep the strip next to your paints. It answers "which one do I like" better than any table can.

Your next small step

If the gouache half felt right, the gouache guide for beginners takes you from four tubes to a first finished card, with a fix-it table for cracks and mud. If your shapes felt wobbly on both halves, the paint is not the problem: a few weeks with our drawing plan will help both.